"The first website to check for your list of all the most popular webcomics and top new up & coming comics!"
Webcomics ~ Top 100 ~ Reviews ~ List of Webcomics


Showing posts with label Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reviews. Show all posts

Friday, March 28, 2008

WEBCOMIC: Marry Me


Marry Me


Webcomic URL: http://www.marrymemovie.com/main/
Webcomic RSS feed: http://www.marrymemovie.com/
main/feed/atom/


Artist/Author: Bobby Crosby & Remy "Eisu" Mokhtar
Updates: irregular



Description:
"Marry Me is a romantic comedy graphic novel about a pop star, frustrated with her love life, who marries a random fan holding a “MARRY ME” sign at one of her concerts."
-- http://www.marrymemovie.com/
main/about/


"Marry Me" is a online comic/graphic novel... about a fictional pop idol named Stasia and appears to parody the obsessive response to the private lives of pop idols... "Marry Me" is an ongoing project that currently exists as an online comic presented in the format of a printed comic book or graphic novel... "

"The strip revolves around a fictional pop star by the name of Stasia (short for Anastasia), who is revealed to have a history of doing impulsive and often ill-advised things both on and off stage. The central plot feature of the comic is by far the most crazy stunt to date. On the last concert of her tour Stasia decides that she wants to skip dating and boyfriends entirely, and that she is willing to marry pretty much anyone. In the front row of the audience, she sees a man holding a sign that says "Marry Me" and she pulls the concert goer, named Guy from the audience and, with the help of a minister who also happens to be in the audience, marries him on stage in front of thousands of fans. Guy, who is largely unaware of Stasia's history, and who is only holding sign for his Stasia-obsessed friend Parker, goes along with the stunt without realizing that there will be serious consequences."
-- Wikipedia entry for "Marry Me"



Reviews:
"Stasia, the star of the show, manages to both seem real and fundamentally human, not only in spite of, but possibly because of her disconnect from reality. She's a pop star, fabulously wealthy and famous, used to similarly famous boyfriends, and adored by millions of fans - and frustrated with a life where no one takes her seriously, and no one who really knows who she is, least of all herself.

It is a predictable story, but somehow still an enjoyable read. It takes skill to pull it altogether - to make us feel sympathy for this fabulously rich girl whose problems are all of her own invention - but [Bobby Crosby] manages to do it. ...the art is fantastic, and that is the work of one Remy "Eisu" Mokhtar, creator of No Pink Ponies, and all-around genius artist. Eisu manages to give the art a flair all of its own, and shows real skill for capturing each character's mood through expressions and body language.

Lively art, clever jokes, and an enjoyable story make this a worthwhile read. The drive to bring all that together makes it into a whole lot more..."
-- Broken Fronteir

"...the good part: I have to say that Remy’s art is quite attractive. His characters are all excellently designed: each distinct and oftentimes adorable. He plays around with several camera angles, and all look natural... no complaints about the art... However, the story is totally, utterly ludicrious and on the verge of being painful. At no point is the story even remotely believable."

"The portrayal of Stasia is wildly incosistent, and there’s nothing in the comic that makes her likable at all... [Guy] is such an utter bore, though, that it’s almost not worth mentioning... And then there’s the awful dialogue... ...the only interesting character is probably Parker Webber, Guy’s lesbian friend, and only because she’s realistically over the top."

"I’ll give Marry Me one point for the art and one point for Ms. Webber, but beyond those two, there’s not much to recommend."

"Rating: 2 stars (out of a possible 5)"
-- The Webcomic Overlook

"...it is a romantic comedy drawn in a mildly manga-ish sort of style, and its website is bright pink. However, the writing and art are both excellent, and the storyline contains enough snappy humour to make up for elements that would generally turn me... off. So far, the writer is handling the genre well. His characters have the potential to be cliches, but they seem to be slowly wriggling their ways out of the Rom-Com Caricature Trap. Though the story may eventually turn out to follow all the usual tired old conventions, the writer shows signs of wanting to veer off in unexpected directions. The archive is currently manageable and takes well under an hour to get through."
-- The Massey College Alumni Association

"From the first page I was very impressed with the artwork. Remy Mokhtar is a diamond in the webcomic rough... The coloring is excellent... Shading is used to great effect and the colors compliment each other nicely. Quality, professional work...

"The storytelling fell into place right along with the artwork. Bobby has a firm grasp on humor... Things moved along briskly as well. Some soap opera style comics tend to drag where pacing is concerned, but so far that isn't happening here. I didn't find myself wanting to rush through the pages, and actually was hoping the archive was bigger when it stopped at 14 pages.

"In closing I only see good things in store for this comic. ..with high quality writing and artwork like this I can recommend it to anyone looking for a new comic to enjoy and bookmark...

"This comic is....Highly Recommended"
-- Webcomic Asylum



Comic 1's Review:
I found "Marry Me" to be quite entertaining and a very pleasant read. While every situation or action in the story may not be realistic or believable, it is refreshing to see a "real-world" story without superheroes, talking animals, or spell-slinging wizards. Of course, chances are that nothing like this is going to happen in the real world, but the fact that it could happen helps the reader to relate to the characters and get "into" the story.

Character development seems to have been sacrificed for the sake of moving the storyline along. There's obviously more to each of the characters than what the reader gets to see, but the pace of the story prevents him from really getting to know them. It's almost like reading a well-written action novel, then watching a movie production of the same story, where much of the depth and richness of detail has been lost in the adaptation. The story does move fast, often leaving the reader with feeling that he might have missed something.

Although somewhat shallow, each of the characters have distinct personalities, and a couple of them are quite endearing to the readers. Their facial expressions do a wonderful job of conveying their emotions and help to carry the story in places where the dialogue might be found lacking. The characters are surprisingly easy to relate to. It doesn't take long for the reader to find himself feeling sorry for one character or cheering on another. Ironically, one of the supporting characters -- Parker -- seems to be the hands-down favorite among fans. Parker is, by far, the most memorable of the cast, and at times seems poised to upstage Stasia, her idol, for the role of lead character.

There have been some problems with keeping up with the updating schedule, and as the story progresses, it begins to feel somewhat "rushed." At this time, the first run of "Marry Me" is slated to end at around 90 pages. Perhaps after the initial storyline is in place, the comic will continue with a less rigorous schedule, leaving the author free to tell his story without imposing deadlines and space limitations hanging over his head.

The whole premise for "Marry Me" is a fascinating concept for a webcomic, and the art is fantastic. While it may not be for everyone, it's definitely worth checking out. Read the descriptions & reviews, and if it sounds like something that you might enjoy, go check it out.
-- Comic 1



For those concerned with content, here's the content that some might find objectionable (as of the time of this review, 67 pages in)...
-- One panel contains "brief nudity" and some of the "pop star" outfits were rather skimpy.
-- One mildly obscene word was used early in the story.
-- Adult themes (lesbianism & a "threesome") were briefly discussed.
-- A couple of the characters are involved in a skirmish, where a punch or two was thrown.
-- A couple of characters are depicted drinking blood as part of an African tribal ritual.



Saturday, March 22, 2008

WEBCOMIC: The Phoenix Requiem


The Phoenix Requiem


Webcomic URL: http://requiem.seraph-inn.com/
Webcomic RSS feed: http://requiem.seraph-inn.com/updates.rss

Artist/Author: Sarah Ellerton
Updates: Monday & Thursday



Description:
The Phoenix Requiem is a graphic novel that will span 5 volumes when it is finished.

"In a cold, industrial-era land, a wounded man stumbles into the quiet and humble town of Esk. Fleeing a past of troubles which he would rather forget, he quickly befriends Anya, a young lady struggling to become a doctor in spite of the disapproval of her family and friends of this distinctly non-traditional path.

When the old and the weak begin dying of an horrific and unnatural plague, and the souls of the dead begin to wander the streets, people begin to pray that the magic-bringing spirits of old - imprisoned by traitors - will finally break free in this time of need."
-- http://requiem.seraph-inn.com/about.html



Reviews:
"It's surprising to find such a polished webcomic with painted backdrops and such clean linework. Characters are pleasingly rendered, with a soft delicate color palette, and there is really a good use of perspectives and backdrops..."
-- mangarevolution

" The artwork is slightly manga based like Gun Baby, and like Gun Baby the comic is strengthen by the way the artist has taken on some of mangas qualities and removed other parts not necessary for the story. The story seems to have references to Sarah Ellerton’s previous comic Inverloch which has now finished. Also with a bi-weekly release of 2 or 3 pages at a time the wait between pages doesn’t seem so bad and the plot can progress at a fair rate. One to watch as it will probably win at least one award at the WCCA with the amount of nominations it has received."
-- The Scienteers

"...Sarah Ellerton continues to amaze me with how much her skills have grown. The improvements in her artwork is easy to notice; what strikes me is not the skill of her backgrounds or the depths of detail (both of which are better than what most professional print cartoonists can put forth), but in the poses and blocking utilized as Ellerton shows her story. Indeed, her ability with drawn facial expressions and body language alone allow Ellerton to reveal a story with a minimum of words. In some ways I feel like TPR is more a movie we're glimpsing moments of rather than a traditional webcomic. ...It's these little touches that have helped bring The Phoenix Requiem to life, and make it a worthy successor for Inverloch."
-- Robert A. Howard of Tangents



In early February, WCCA (Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards) released its nominees for 2008. The Phoenix Requiem was nominated for the following:
  • Outstanding Comic Finalists
  • Outstanding Newcomer Finalists
  • Outstanding Artist Finalists
  • Outstanding Writer Finalists
  • Outstanding Character Writing Finalists
  • Outstanding Long Form Comic Finalists
  • Outstanding Dramatic Comic Finalists
  • Outstanding Layout Finalists
  • Outstanding Use of Color Finalists
  • Outstanding Character Rendering Finalists
  • Outstanding Environment Design Finalists
You can check out the list in its entirety at COMIXTALK.


Thursday, February 28, 2008

WEBCOMIC: Hamleto The Hamster



Hamleto The Hamster


Webcomic URL: http://hamletothehamster.blogspot.com/
Webcomic RSS feed: http://hamletothehamster.blogspot.com/rss.xml

Artist/Author: Valentina "TYN" Sgaggero
Updates: Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday



Description:
"A comic strip about the daily adventure of a cute yet sarcastic hamster and his young and naive owner."
-- http://www.comixpedia.org/index.php?
title=Hamleto_The_Hamster


"Hamleto The Hamster is a comic strip that speaks about hamsters and people.
In other words, it's a comic strip that speaks about animals."

-- http://hamletothehamster.blogspot.com/


"Hamleto the Hamster" is written & drawn by Valentina "TYN" Sgaggero. It is updated three times per week, on Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday. Hamleto is usually a 3-panel, gag-a-day webcomic, but occasionally runs a 4+ strip story. It is the story of the daily life and adventures of a hamster and his friends.

Hamleto shares a cage with his "roommate," Laerte, and enjoys frequent visits from Orazio, yet another hamster, who belongs to a friend of Hamleto's owner. They have the sort of adventures that hamsters have -- and other adventures that hamsters would have, if they could.

Hamleto is egotistical & self-centered, but in a loveable, Garfield-ish sort of way. He can be an anti-social bully until one wins his favor, but he's also creative and resourceful. He is adventuresome and dreams of traveling the world... and he loves Elvis. Much of the comedy is drawn from Hamleto's sarcasm or the mean tricks that he plays on the other hamsters.

Alice is Hamleto's owner. She's young, but responsible, constantly referring to a manual to learn more about hamsters. Alice's friend Elisa often brings her own hamster, Orazio, over to visit Hamleto.

Orazio is refined & sensible, as opposed to Hamleto's crudeness and sense of adventure. Although they got off to a rough start, Hamleto now accepts Orazio as a friend.

Laerte is Hamleto's naive, obnoxiously over-friendly roommate. He is a Russian hamster from a family of circus performers and was once an acrobat himself. He constantly tries to befriend Hamleto and Orazio, but his eagerness to make friends has thus far prevented this. As a result, he usually ends up the butt of their jokes & victim of their pranks. He is the smallest of the lot, has been beaten up on occasion, and is picked on mercilessly by not only Hamleto, but also Orazio.



Comic 1's Review:
Hamleto is a light-hearted read and at times very funny. It is well-suited to the entire family, especially those who've had hamsters for pets. Many of the habits & traits of real-life hamsters are explored in this comic and find themselves to be the subject of its humor.

Each of the main cast members has his or her own personality that emerges as the strips progress. ...And TYN does a wonderful job of keeping her thrice-weekly schedule. The artwork is simple but professional, which draws the reader's attention to the characters and the jokes that they're trying to convey. The humor itself rarely misses, ranging from simply entertaining to laugh-out-loud hilarious.

I'd recommend this webcomic to anyone who has a hamster, has ever had a hamster, wants a hamster, thinks hamsters are cute, knows what a hamster is, etc. If you've ever found yourself laughing at videos of comical animal antics, then chances are that Hamleto is for you. If you're looking for a good, clean, family-friendly webcomic that is actually funny, then you've found it. Go check out Hamleto!
-- Comic 1


Friday, February 22, 2008

WEBCOMIC: Calamities of Nature



Calamities of Nature


Webcomic URL: http://www.calamitiesofnature.com/
Webcomic RSS feed: http://feeds.feedburner.com/calamitiesofnature

Artist/Author: Tony Piro
Updates: Monday & Thursday



Description:
"The stories are about the friends Aaron, Alp, Ferdinand, and Harold and their wacky adventures... Some of the stories are fairly silly... [but others] include some social commentary as well."
-- http://www.calamitiesofnature.com/about/



Reviews:
"This comic has such a unique style, the colors are amazing, the characters are fun to hang with..."

"A breath of fresh air in the smoggy wasteland that is webcomic surfing."

"Likable characters, funny script. Great work!"
-- Comments at OnlineComics

"Funny stories about Aaron the Mole, Harold the Hamster, Ferdinand the Groundhog, and Alp the Alien. Deals with silly topics such as chest hair and subliminal message machines, but always in a tasteful manner. Sometimes current events and issues are discussed, but never with a strong political bent. I guarantee that you'll laugh or your money back. No really, I mean it."
-- Family Webcomics

This same description is found on a number of other sites as well, so it's probably not original to Family Webcomics. At any rate, there's the link to the "Calamities of Nature" listing at Family Webcomics.



Comic 1's Review:
"Calamities of Nature" by Tony Piro is a fairly new, well-drawn furry that will remind you of the classic color Sunday newspaper comics. The characters are likeable and easy to get to know, and the storylines are usually light and humorous, although they will occasionally touch on politics, but in a light-hearted way. The archive isn't all that deep yet, but with updates coming twice weekly, it's growing. "Calamities of Nature" is a webcomic that has all the ingredients for success, and one that will likely become quite popular as more folks discover it.
-- Comic 1